greytHR Growth Partner · Fort, Mumbai[email protected]
Payroll WorldgreytHR Growth Partner
Guide · updated 20 November 2026

Payroll software vs Excel: when should you switch?

Excel works for a handful of employees. Here's where it starts to cost you — and what changes when you move to software like greytHR.

Is it safe to run payroll on Excel?

Excel can work for very small teams, but risk rises quickly with headcount, multiple states, shifts and tax proofs. Formula errors, version mix-ups and missed statutory changes lead to wrong salaries and penalties. Payroll software automates calculations, compliance updates and employee self-service.

ExcelPayroll software (e.g. greytHR)
CalculationsManual formulas; easy to breakConfigured engine; consistent every month
Statutory updatesYou track and edit every changeApplied automatically (per greytHR)
Attendance → payrollCopy-paste from devicesPunches flow directly into payroll
Returns & challansPrepared separatelyECR, ESI challans, eTDS returns generated
Payslips & tax docsEmailed manuallySelf-service app for every employee
SecurityFiles on laptops and emailRole-based access, encryption, audit logs
Key-person riskDepends on one personProcess lives in the system

Signs it's time to switch

  • You've crossed 20–25 employees or added a second state
  • Month-end payroll takes more than a day
  • Employees keep asking HR for payslips, leave balances or Form 16
  • You've paid a late fee or interest on PF, ESI or TDS
  • Only one person understands the payroll sheet

Frequently asked questions

At what size should a company move off Excel payroll?

There's no fixed number, but once you have multiple states, shifts or 20+ employees, the time and compliance risk usually outweigh the software cost.

How much does payroll software cost?

greytHR starts at ₹2,495/month for up to 50 employees, with a 7-day free trial.

Can we import our Excel data into greytHR?

Yes. greytHR lists Excel import among its Core HR features.

Sources:

This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. Rules change and vary by state — confirm with your CA or labour-law advisor.

Free demoPricing