Excel can work for very small teams, but risk rises quickly with headcount, multiple states, shifts and tax proofs. Formula errors, version mix-ups and missed statutory changes lead to wrong salaries and penalties. Payroll software automates calculations, compliance updates and employee self-service.
| Excel | Payroll software (e.g. greytHR) | |
|---|---|---|
| Calculations | Manual formulas; easy to break | Configured engine; consistent every month |
| Statutory updates | You track and edit every change | Applied automatically (per greytHR) |
| Attendance → payroll | Copy-paste from devices | Punches flow directly into payroll |
| Returns & challans | Prepared separately | ECR, ESI challans, eTDS returns generated |
| Payslips & tax docs | Emailed manually | Self-service app for every employee |
| Security | Files on laptops and email | Role-based access, encryption, audit logs |
| Key-person risk | Depends on one person | Process lives in the system |
Signs it's time to switch
- You've crossed 20–25 employees or added a second state
- Month-end payroll takes more than a day
- Employees keep asking HR for payslips, leave balances or Form 16
- You've paid a late fee or interest on PF, ESI or TDS
- Only one person understands the payroll sheet
Frequently asked questions
At what size should a company move off Excel payroll?
There's no fixed number, but once you have multiple states, shifts or 20+ employees, the time and compliance risk usually outweigh the software cost.
How much does payroll software cost?
greytHR starts at ₹2,495/month for up to 50 employees, with a 7-day free trial.
Can we import our Excel data into greytHR?
Yes. greytHR lists Excel import among its Core HR features.
Sources:
This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. Rules change and vary by state — confirm with your CA or labour-law advisor.